Upgrading your front door is the most impactful change you can make to your smart home in 2026. But the market is split into two camps.
In one corner, we have the August Wi-Fi Smart Lock, the champion of "Retrofitting," which promises to make your door smart without changing its look. In the other corner, the Schlage Encode, a complete "Replacement" beast that brings a keypad and heavy-duty security hardware. Which approach is right for your home? Let's break down the pros and cons.
The Core Difference: Installation & Aesthetics
This is the deciding factor for 80% of buyers.
August Wi-Fi (The Renter's Dream)
The August lock only replaces the thumb-turn on the inside of your door.
From the Outside: Your door looks exactly the same. You keep your original physical keys. Your landlord won't even know it's there.
The Vibe: "Stealth Smart." It’s discreet.
Schlage Encode (The Homeowner's Choice)
The Schlage Encode replaces the entire deadbolt mechanism, inside and out.
From the Outside: You get a modern touchscreen keypad. It looks high-tech and acts as a visual deterrent to burglars.
The Vibe: "Fortress Smart." It screams security.
Access Methods: Phone vs. Keypad
How do you actually get in if you forget your phone?
Schlage Encode: It has a built-in keypad. This is a lifesaver. If your phone dies, you just type your 4-digit PIN. It’s also perfect for giving codes to dog walkers or contractors without forcing them to download an app.
August Wi-Fi: It relies heavily on "Auto-Unlock" (using your phone's Bluetooth/GPS to unlock as you approach). It works like magic... 95% of the time. If your phone battery dies, you must use your physical key. To get a keypad, you have to buy a separate accessory ($50 extra) and stick it to your wall.
Battery Life: The Wi-Fi Struggle
Both locks connect directly to Wi-Fi (no hub needed), which is convenient but power-hungry.
- Schlage Encode: Uses 4 AA batteries. Lasts about 5-6 months. It’s physically larger, so it has room for more juice.
- August Wi-Fi: Uses 2 CR123A batteries. Because the device is so small, battery life is its biggest weakness, often lasting only 3-4 months.
Comparison Table: 2026 Specs
| Feature | August Wi-Fi Smart Lock | Schlage Encode |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Retrofit (Inside only) | Full Replacement (Deadbolt) |
| Keypad | Sold Separately | Built-in Touchscreen |
| Security Rating | Dependent on your old deadbolt | ANSI Grade 1 (Highest possible) |
| Motor Noise | Quiet mechanical whir | Loud, industrial clunk |
The "Auto-Unlock" Feature
This is August's secret weapon. Because August has been refining its software for a decade, its Auto-Unlock feature is the best in the industry. It detects when you arrive home and unlocks the door before you even reach for the handle. Schlage doesn't offer native auto-unlock (for security reasons), requiring you to enter a code or use the app.
FAQ: Which One fits Your Door?
Is Schlage hard to install?
It’s slightly harder than August because you have to unscrew and remove your old deadbolt completely. However, it still only requires a Philips screwdriver and takes about 15-20 minutes. No drilling is usually required for standard doors.
Does August work with warped doors?
If you have to push or pull your door hard to get it to lock, August will struggle. The motor isn't as powerful as your hand. You must fix your door alignment (strike plate) before installing any smart lock.
Choose August Wi-Fi if: You are a Renter, live in an apartment, or want to keep your existing designer door hardware.
Choose Schlage Encode if: You are a Homeowner, have a busy family (kids needing codes), and want the highest physical security rating available (Grade 1).